Orange County Government  
Orange County Administration Center  
201 S Rosalind Ave.  
Orlando, FL 32802-1393  
Draft Meeting Minutes  
Tuesday, March 5, 2024  
9:00 AM  
County Commission Chambers  
Board of County Commissioners  
Language Assistance and Translation Services Available:  
Para asistencia lingüística o servicios de traducción en español, llame al (407) 836-3111  
Si w bezwen èd nan lang Kreyòl oswa sèvis tradiksyon, tanpri rele (407) 836-3111  
Call to Order  
County Vice Mayor Nicole H. Wilson called the meeting to order at 9:11 a.m.  
7 -  
Present:  
Mayor Jerry L. Demings, Commissioner Nicole Wilson, Commissioner Christine  
Moore, Commissioner Mayra Uribe, Commissioner Maribel Gomez Cordero,  
Commissioner Emily Bonilla, and Commissioner Michael Scott  
Others present:  
County Comptroller Phil Diamond as Clerk  
County Administrator Byron Brooks  
Deputy County Administrator Jon Weiss  
County Attorney Jeffrey J. Newton  
Deputy County Attorney Georgiana Holmes  
Public Works Director Joseph Kunkel  
Minutes Supervisor Craig Stopyra  
Minutes Coordinator Megan Fiocco  
Minutes Coordinator Terrell Hightower  
Invocation - District 3  
Reverend Kevin Bartle, St. Mary of the Angels Episcopal Church  
Pledge of Allegiance  
Presentation  
Proclamation recognizing March 3 through March 9, 2024 as National Consumer Protection  
Week  
Presentation  
Proclamation recognizing March as Procurement Month  
Public Comment  
The following persons addressed the Board during public comment:  
- Chris Mathieson  
- Janét Buford-Johnson  
I.  
CONSENT AGENDA  
Approval of the Consent Agenda  
The Mayor deferred action on County Administrator Item 1A; and further, a motion was made by  
Commissioner Uribe, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, to approve the balance of  
the Consent Agenda. The motion carried by the following vote:  
5 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Uribe, Commissioner  
Gomez Cordero, and Commissioner Scott  
2 - Commissioner Moore, and Commissioner Bonilla  
A. COUNTY COMPTROLLER  
Absent:  
1.  
meeting and the minutes of the February 6, 2024 meeting of the Board of  
County Commissioners. (Clerk’s Office)  
2.  
County funds, having been certified that no accounts have been overdrawn  
due to the issuance of same.  
Disbursement periods cover:  
- February 16, 2024 to February 22, 2024; $55,108,512.56  
- February 23, 2024 to February 29, 2024; $55,963,356.41  
(Finance/Accounting)  
B. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR  
1.  
Development Office)  
A. Environmental Protection Commission: Reappointment of Peter J. Fleck  
in the regulated business or municipality representative category, Kelly S.  
Eger-Smith in the environmental specialist representative category, and  
Margaret Shan Atkins in the recognized conservation organization  
representative category with terms expiring December 31, 2025.  
B. Fire and Life Safety Code Board of Adjustments and Appeals:  
Reappointment of Angelica Corredor in the at large representative category  
with a term expiring December 31, 2026.  
C. MetroPlan Orlando Community Advisory Committee: Appointment of  
Joseph E. Caesar and Glenn Cook to succeed Gislene M. Moorman and  
Patricia Rumph in the Orange County representative category with terms  
expiring December 31, 2027.  
D. Neighborhood Grants Advisory Board: Appointment of Kourtney N.  
Dinkins to succeed Evelyn Reyes in the District 3 representative category  
with a term expiring June 30, 2025.  
(County Administrator Item 1A was deferred. County Administrator Consent Items 1B, 1C, and 1D  
were approved.)  
2.  
the Town of Eatonville Community Redevelopment Agency with a term  
expiring June 30, 2028. (Agenda Development Office)  
3.  
4.  
Marrero as the District 4 representative on the Orange County Citizen Corps  
Council with a term expiring December 31, 2024. (Agenda Development  
Office)  
MSTU Advisory Board of Douglas M. Spencer and Chad E. Wilkins with  
terms expiring December 31, 2025 and appointment of Richard L. Yates  
with a term expiring December 31, 2024. (Agenda Development Office)  
5.  
6.  
7.  
8.  
Denise M. Hammond to the Lake Sue Advisory Board with terms expiring  
December 31, 2024. (Agenda Development Office)  
the municipal elected official category with a term expiring December 31,  
2025. (Agenda Development Office)  
Appraiser in the amount of $6,741,680.53. (Office of Management and  
Budget)  
#24-24. (Office of Management and Budget)  
C. ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES DEPARTMENT  
1.  
2.  
3.  
4.  
Removal and Supplies, to the low responsive and responsible bidder,  
Healthcare Environmental Services, LLC. The estimated contract award  
amount is $112,859.70 for a one-year term. ([Health Services Department  
Fiscal and Operational Support Division] Procurement Division)  
- Goldenrod Area Section I, to the low responsive and responsible bidder,  
Lawnwalker Services, Inc. The estimated contract award amount is  
$354,353 for the base year. ([Public Works Department Roads and  
Drainage Division] Procurement Division)  
- John Young Area Section II, to the low responsive and responsible bidder,  
Aero Groundtek, LLC. The estimated contract award amount is $751,538 for  
the base year. ([Public Works Department Roads and Drainage Division]  
Procurement Division)  
Services for Orange County Medical Clinic and Corrections Health, to the  
low responsive and responsible bidder, Quest Diagnostics Clinical  
Laboratories, Inc. The estimated contract award amount is $630,620.20 for  
a one-year term. ([Health Services Department Fiscal and Operational  
Support Division] Procurement Division)  
5.  
Operation of Motorized Roll Up Doors, Gate Arms and Dock Levelers, to the  
low responsive and responsible bidder, C&D Industrial Maintenance, LLC.  
The estimated contract award amount is $1,671,360 for a three-year term.  
([Convention Center Facility Operations Division] Procurement Division)  
6.  
Deliveries, to the low responsive and responsible bidder, Palmdale Oil  
Company, LLC. The estimated contract award amount is $2,255,568.03 for  
a one-year term. ([Administrative Services Department Fleet Management  
Division] Procurement Division)  
7.  
to the low responsive and responsible bidder, Trail Saw and Mower Service  
for lines 2, 4, 5, 6, 9, 12, 14, 17, 20, 22, 23, and 26. The estimated contract  
award amount is $307,000 for a one-year term. ([Administrative Services  
Department Fleet Management Division] Procurement Division)  
8.  
Servicing of Portable Fire Extinguishers, to the sole responsive and  
responsible bidder, Cintas Corporation No. 2. The estimated contract award  
amount is $605,400 for a three-year term. ([Administration and Fiscal  
Services Risk Management Division] Procurement Division)  
9.  
Improvements, to the low responsive and responsible bidder, S. A. Casey  
Construction, Inc. The total contract award amount is $273,801.62.  
([Planning, Environmental, and Development Services Department Planning  
Division] Procurement Division)  
10.  
11.  
12.  
Related Equipment for the Orange County Convention Center (OCCC), with  
Freeman Decorating, in the estimated contract award amount of $200,000  
for a one-year term. ([Convention Center Fiscal and Operational Support  
Division] Procurement Division)  
County Wide Roof Maintenance and Repairs, with Advanced Roofing, Inc., in  
the amount of $399,100.25, for a revised estimated contract award amount  
of $1,330,365.75. ([Administrative Services Department Facilities  
Management Division] Procurement Division)  
Dog, with Nextran Corporation dba Nextran Truck Center Orlando, in the  
amount of $176,728.16. ([Utilities Department Solid Waste Division]  
Procurement Division)  
13.  
Assistance for Housing and Urban Development-Funded Community  
Development Programs, with Mosaic Community Planning LLC, in the  
amount of $25,050, for a revised total amount of $128,800.50. ([Planning,  
Environmental, and Development Services Department Housing and  
Community Development Division] Procurement Division)  
14.  
15.  
Bridge Replacement over Lake Butler and Lake Louise Canal, Request for  
Proposals, Y24-801-GO. ([Public Works Department Engineering Division]  
Procurement Division)  
Florida and Melvin Bush and Angela Bush, approval of Sidewalk Easement  
between Melvin Bush and Angela Bush and Orange County, and  
authorization to disburse funds, record instrument, and perform all actions  
necessary and incidental to settlement for Beggs Road and Mott Avenue.  
District 2. (Real Estate Management Division)  
16.  
17.  
Board of County Commissioners to Duke Energy Florida, LLC, d/b/a Duke  
Energy and authorization to record instrument for Fire Station #80  
B2290057 OCU File #99527. District 5. (Real Estate Management Division)  
between Horizons Silverleaf Development, LLC and Pulte Home Company,  
LLC and Orange County and authorization to record instrument for  
PR-23-06-032 Silverleaf Oaks at Hamlin Phase 3A (Drainage, Utility,  
Sidewalk, and Access Easement). District 1. (Real Estate Management  
Division)  
18.  
Florida and Harbor House of Central Florida, Inc. related to not-for-profit  
community center utilization for the provision of services benefitting the  
public and authorization for the Manager of the Community Action Division to  
exercise renewal options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the  
License Agreement, as needed for Harbor House of Central Florida, Inc.  
John Bridges Community Center (CAD) 445 W. 13th Street, Apopka,  
Florida 32703. Lease File #10280. District 2. (Real Estate Management  
Division)  
19.  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC East Orange Community Center  
(CAD) 12050 E. Colonial Dr., Orlando, Florida 32826. Lease File #10285.  
District 4. (Real Estate Management Division)  
20.  
21.  
22.  
23.  
24.  
25.  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC Hal P. Marston Community Center  
(CAD) 3933 Wd Judge Dr., Orlando, Florida 32808. Lease File #10286.  
District 6. (Real Estate Management Division)  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC Holden Heights Community  
Center (CAD) 1201 20th Street, Orlando, Florida 32805. Lease File  
#10287. District 6. (Real Estate Management Division)  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC John Bridges Community Center  
(CAD) 445 W. 13th Street, Apopka, Florida 32703. Lease File #10288.  
District 2. (Real Estate Management Division)  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC Lila Mitchell Community Center  
(CAD) 5151 Raleigh Street, Orlando, Florida 32811. Lease File #10289.  
District 6. (Real Estate Management Division)  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC Maxey Community Center (CAD)  
830 Klondike Street, Winter Garden, Florida 34787. Lease File #10290.  
District 1. (Real Estate Management Division)  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC Multicultural Center (CAD) 7149  
W. Colonial Drive, Orlando, Florida 32818. Lease File #10291. District 6.  
(Real Estate Management Division)  
26.  
27.  
28.  
29.  
30.  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC Pine Hills Community Center  
(CAD) 6400 Jennings Road, Orlando, Florida 32818. Lease File #10292.  
District 6. (Real Estate Management Division)  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC Taft Community Center (CAD)  
9450 S. Orange Avenue, Orlando, Florida 32824. Lease File #10293.  
District 3. (Real Estate Management Division)  
Florida and K2 Medical Research LLC related to community center  
utilization for the provision of services benefitting the public and authorization  
for the Manager of the Community Action Division to exercise renewal  
options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the License Agreement,  
as needed for K2 Medical Research LLC Tangelo Park Community Center  
(CAD) 5160 Pueblo Street, Orlando, Florida 32819. Lease File #10294.  
District 6. (Real Estate Management Division)  
Chamber of Commerce, Inc. Resident Service Provider Agreement and  
authorization for the Manager of the Real Estate Management Division to  
exercise renewal options, execute a termination notice, and furnish notices,  
required, or allowed by the Agreement, as needed for Indian American  
Chamber of Commerce, Inc. NEC at Fashion Square Mall 3201 E. Colonial  
Drive, Orlando, Florida 32803. Lease File #2062-RSP14. District 5. (Real  
Estate Management Division)  
Florida and Primary Care Access Network, Inc. related to not-for-profit  
community center utilization for the provision of services benefitting the  
public and authorization for the Manager of the Community Action Division to  
exercise renewal options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the  
License Agreement, as needed for Primary Care Access Network, Inc. John  
Bridges Community Center (CAD) 445 W. 13th Street, Apopka, Florida  
32703. Lease File #10276. District 2. (Real Estate Management Division)  
31.  
Florida and Primary Care Access Network, Inc. related to not-for-profit  
community center utilization for the provision of services benefitting the  
public and authorization for the Manager of the Community Action Division to  
exercise renewal options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the  
License Agreement, as needed for Primary Care Access Network, Inc.  
Maxey Community Center (CAD) 830 Klondike Street, Winter Garden,  
Florida 34787. Lease File #10277. District 1. (Real Estate Management  
Division)  
32.  
Florida and Primary Care Access Network, Inc. related to not-for-profit  
community center utilization for the provision of services benefitting the  
public and authorization for the Manager of the Community Action Division to  
exercise renewal options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the  
License Agreement, as needed for Primary Care Access Network, Inc.  
Multicultural Center (CAD) 7149 W. Colonial Drive, Orlando, Florida 32818.  
Lease File #10248. District 6. (Real Estate Management Division)  
33.  
Florida and Primary Care Access Network, Inc. related to not-for-profit  
community center utilization for the provision of services benefitting the  
public and authorization for the Manager of the Community Action Division to  
exercise renewal options, and furnish notice, required, or allowed by the  
License Agreement, as needed for Primary Care Access Network, Inc.  
Tangelo Park Community Center (CAD) 5160 Pueblo Street, Orlando,  
Florida 32819. Lease File #10249. District 6. (Real Estate Management  
Division)  
D. COMMUNITY AND FAMILY SERVICES DEPARTMENT  
1.  
for 2024-2025 to establish a formal selection process for eligible children  
and families. All Districts. (Head Start Division)  
E. HEALTH SERVICES DEPARTMENT  
1.  
and Orange County regarding funding to construct Medical Examiner’s  
Office Expansion and authorization for the Mayor or designee to sign future  
amendments to the agreement, if necessary, upon the mutual written  
agreement of the parties. Osceola County agrees to pay Orange County  
$6,000,000 in three consecutive installments of $2,000,000 starting FY  
2023-2024 and ending with FY 2025-2026. (Medical Examiner’s Office)  
2.  
Florida and Orlando Health Sciences College, LLC D/B/A Orlando College  
of Osteopathic Medicine related to Experiential Learning Placement  
Program with a term beginning on the day of execution and ending  
September 30, 2024 and authorization for the Mayor or designee to sign  
future amendments to the agreement, if necessary, upon the mutual written  
agreement of the parties.  
3.  
and Necessity for National Health Transport Inc. to provide Interfacility Basic  
Life Support and Advanced Life Support transport services in Orange  
County, Florida. The term of this certificate is from March 8, 2024, through  
March 7, 2026. There is no cost to the County. (EMS Office of the Medical  
Director)  
F. PLANNING, ENVIRONMENTAL, AND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT  
1.  
Real Property between Seminole County, Florida and Orange County,  
Florida for Trinity Preparatory School of Florida. District 5. (Building Safety  
Division)  
2.  
Agreement between Orange County, Florida, and Southwick Commons, Ltd,  
and Neighborhood Lending Partners of Florida, Inc., regarding the  
Affordable Housing Trust Fund Program and American Rescue Plan Funds  
Y21-1046C - Southwick Commons, LTD providing a total amount of  
$3,000,000. District 2. (Housing and Community Development Division)  
G. PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT  
1.  
2.  
3.  
Engineering)  
(Development Engineering)  
Brakes Orange Blossom Trail by and between Publix Super Markets, Inc.  
and Orange County for a proportionate share payment in the amount of  
$84,840. District 2. (Roadway Agreement Committee)  
4.  
5.  
Jamaican Restaurant Powers Drive by and between Growth Property  
Management LLC and Orange County for a proportionate share payment in  
the amount of $75,651. District 6. (Roadway Agreement Committee)  
PD AKA Tyson Ranch MFU Boggy Creek Road by and among Boggy  
Creek Commercial, LLC, Orlando Airport Property, LLC, and Orange  
County for a proportionate share payment in the amount of $1,273,970.  
District 4. (Roadway Agreement Committee)  
6.  
PD AKA Tyson Ranch Hotel Boggy Creek Road by and between Boggy  
Creek Commercial, LLC and Orange County for a proportionate share  
payment in the amount of $900,565. District 4. (Roadway Agreement  
Committee)  
7.  
PD - Commercial/Retail AKA Tyson Retail Boggy Creek Road by and  
between Boggy Creek Commercial, LLC and Orange County for a  
proportionate share payment in the amount of $263,580. District 4.  
(Roadway Agreement Committee)  
8.  
9.  
the Orlando Urban Area Metropolitan Planning Organization D/B/A/  
MetroPlan Orlando. All Districts. (Transportation Planning Division)  
Board of County Commissioners regarding the Local Agency Program  
Agreement with the State of Florida Department of Transportation  
concerning the Tiny Road intersection improvements at Tilden Road Project  
(FPN Number 444788-1-58/68-01) and (2) State of Florida Department of  
Transportation Local Agency Program Agreement FPN: 444788-1-58-01  
and FPN: 444788-1-68-01. District 1. (Transportation Planning)  
10.  
452932-1-52-01 Resolution 2024-M-06 of the Orange County Board of  
County Commissioners regarding the Locally Funded Agreement with the  
State of Florida Department of Transportation concerning State Road  
50/Colonial Drive intersection of State Road 50 with Corner School Drive  
and (2) Locally Funded Agreement between the State of Florida Department  
of Transportation and Orange County FPN: 452932-1-52-01. District 5.  
(Transportation Planning Division)  
11.  
12.  
13.  
Avenue and 37th Street. District 6. (Traffic Engineering Division)  
and 37th Street. District 6. (Traffic Engineering Division)  
to completion of Subdivision Improvements (Silverleaf Reserve at Hamlin  
Phase 2C) by and between Orange County and Meritage Homes of Florida,  
Inc. District 1. (Development Engineering)  
II.  
DISCUSSION AGENDA  
A. ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES DEPARTMENT  
1.  
for Orange County Convention Center North-South Building Food Service  
Renovations, Request for Proposals Y24-807-MB, from the following three  
firms, listed alphabetically:  
- Architectural Design Collaborative, Inc.  
- Helman Hurley Charvat Peacock/Architects, Inc.  
- KZF Design LLC d.b.a. KMF Architects  
([Convention Center Fiscal and Operational Support Division] Procurement  
Division)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Wilson, seconded by Commissioner Scott, to appoint  
Helman Hurley Charvat Peacock/Architects, Inc., 451 points, as the selected firm; and further,  
appoint KZF Design LLC d.b.a KMF Architects, 443.33 points, and Architectural Design  
Collaborative, Inc., 337.83 points as the selected ranked alternates. The motion carried by the  
following vote:  
5 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Uribe, Commissioner  
Gomez Cordero, and Commissioner Scott  
2 - Commissioner Moore, and Commissioner Bonilla  
III. WORK SESSION AGENDA  
Absent:  
A. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR  
1.  
Board discussion ensued. County Administrator Brooks contributed to the discussion.  
The Board took no action.  
B. PLANNING, ENVIRONMENTAL, AND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT  
1.  
Protection Division)  
Board discussion ensued. County Attorney Newton, and County Administrator Brooks contributed  
to the discussion.  
The motion by Commissioner Scott to approve Item B1(A) from consent, the reappointment of  
Peter Fleck in the regulated business or municipality category was withdrawn.  
The Board took no action.  
and  
I.  
CONSENT AGENDA (Deferred)  
B. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR  
1.  
Development Office)  
A. Environmental Protection Commission: Reappointment of Peter J. Fleck  
in the regulated business or municipality representative category, Kelly S.  
Eger-Smith in the environmental specialist representative category, and  
Margaret Shan Atkins in the recognized conservation organization  
representative category with terms expiring December 31, 2025.  
B. Fire and Life Safety Code Board of Adjustments and Appeals:  
Reappointment of Angelica Corredor in the at large representative category  
with a term expiring December 31, 2026.  
C. MetroPlan Orlando Community Advisory Committee: Appointment of  
Joseph E. Caesar and Glenn Cook to succeed Gislene M. Moorman and  
Patricia Rumph in the Orange County representative category with terms  
expiring December 31, 2027.  
D. Neighborhood Grants Advisory Board: Appointment of Kourtney N.  
Dinkins to succeed Evelyn Reyes in the District 3 representative category  
with a term expiring June 30, 2025.  
The Board only considered County Administrator Consent Item 1A as the other items, County  
Administrator Consent Items 1B, 1C, and 1D were approved previously in the Consent motion.  
The Board took no action.  
Nonagenda  
Mayor Demings commented on a notice provided by the City of Orlando regarding a feasibility  
study for Sunbridge, Stanton, and International Corporation Park Annexation Area. Mayor  
Demings summarized the annexation and explained that the notice was received by surprise. It  
was expressed that communications between City of Orlando and Orange County needs to  
improve for planning purposes including impacts on the Vision 2050 plan. Staff was directed to  
prepare a letter noting concerns and potential issues regarding the proposed annexation to  
present to the city at the March 11, 2024 public hearing which is the first of two regarding this  
matter. Staff will keep this Board informed as to the city's actions and any staff level discussion  
regarding this potential annexation.  
EXECUTIVE SESSION  
Due to the nature of the discussion, this meeting is not open to the public.  
A. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR  
1.  
Fighters (IAFF) Contract Negotiations.  
IV.  
RECOMMENDATIONS  
1.  
A motion was made by Commissioner Uribe, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, to  
approve the recommendations, subject to the usual right of appeal by any aggrieved party. The  
motion carried by the following vote:  
6 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, and Commissioner Bonilla  
1 - Commissioner Scott  
Absent:  
V.  
PUBLIC HEARINGS  
A. Municipal Service Benefit Unit  
1.  
maintenance; District 1  
Consideration: Establish by resolution a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for streetlighting and for  
retention pond(s) maintenance at Avalon Ridge which consists of 46 lots.  
Location: District 1; Section 05, Township 23, Range 27; Orange County, Florida (legal property  
description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Wilson, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, to  
approve the request as referenced in the Staff Report dated February 15, 2024. The motion  
carried by the following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
2.  
retention pond(s) maintenance; District 2  
Consideration: Amend by resolution a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for streetlighting and for  
retention pond(s) maintenance to include Bargrove Phase 2, which will add 67 lots from Bargrove  
Phase 2.  
Location: District 2; Section 09, Township 20, Range 27; Orange County, Florida (legal property  
description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Moore, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, to  
approve the request as referenced in the Staff Report dated February 15, 2024. The motion  
carried by the following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
3.  
maintenance; District 4  
Consideration: Establish by resolution a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for streetlighting and for  
retention pond(s) maintenance at Chase Landing which consists of 68 lots.  
Location: District 4; Section 30, Township 24, Range 30; Orange County, Florida (legal property  
description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, seconded by Commissioner Scott, to  
approve the request as referenced in the Staff Report dated February 15, 2024. The motion  
carried by the following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
4.  
maintenance; District 1  
Consideration: Amend by resolution a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for streetlighting and for  
retention pond(s) maintenance to include Encore at Ovation Phase 4B, which will add 124 lots.  
Location: District 1; Section 19, Township 24, Range 27; Orange County, Florida (legal property  
description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Wilson, seconded by Commissioner Uribe, to approve the  
request as referenced in the Staff Report dated February 15, 2024. The motion carried by the  
following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
5.  
Consideration: Establish by resolution a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for streetlighting at  
Hamlin Pointe which consists of 53 lots.  
Location: District 1; Section 19, Township 23, Range 27; Orange County, Florida (legal property  
description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Wilson, seconded by Commissioner Scott, to approve the  
request as referenced in the Staff Report dated February 15, 2024. The motion carried by the  
following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
6.  
Consideration: Establish by resolution a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for streetlighting at  
Hamlin Ridge which consists of 96 lots.  
Location: District 1; Section 19, Township 23, Range 27; Orange County, Florida (legal property  
description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Wilson, seconded by Commissioner Moore, to approve  
the request as referenced in the Staff Report dated February 15, 2024. The motion carried by the  
following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
7.  
maintenance; District 4  
Consideration: Establish by resolution a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for streetlighting and for  
retention pond(s) maintenance at Hancock Lone Palm which consists of 37 lots.  
Location: District 4; Section 24, Township 22, Range 31; Orange County, Florida (legal property  
description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, seconded by Commissioner Scott, to  
approve the request as referenced in the Staff Report dated February 15, 2024. The motion  
carried by the following vote:  
6 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, and Commissioner Scott  
1 - Commissioner Bonilla  
Absent:  
8.  
Consideration: Establish by resolution a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for streetlighting at  
Handsonhurst which consists of 27 parcels.  
Location: District 3; Multiple Parcels; Section 31, Township 22, Range 30; Orange County,  
Florida (legal property description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Uribe, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, to  
approve the request as referenced in the Staff Report dated February 15, 2024. The motion  
carried by the following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
B. Petition to Vacate  
9.  
Mohammed Islam/NRST LLC, on behalf of 11726 Ruby Lake Land Trust,  
and Noon Foundation Inc., vacate an unopened, unimproved, and unnamed  
alleyway; District 1  
Consideration: Resolution granting Petition to Vacate # 23-01-003, vacating an unopened,  
unimproved, and unnamed 16-foot-wide alleyway located between three undeveloped residential  
parcels located within the Orange Center Subdivision.  
Location: District 1; The parcel addresses are 11696 Ruby Lake Road, 11726 Ruby Lake  
Road, and 11711 Maple Street; S15/T24/R28; Orange County, Florida (legal property description  
on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Wilson, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, to  
approve the request listed in the Staff Report dated March 5, 2024. The motion carried by the  
following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
10.  
Cutter Smyth of Carrigan Reality Inc., on behalf of Sherri L Carrigan, vacate  
a portion of an unopened and unmaintained right-of-way; District 5  
Consideration: Resolution granting Petition to Vacate # 23-01-001, vacating an approximately  
15-foot-wide by 60-foot-long portion of an unopened and unmaintained right-of-way known as  
11th Avenue and lies along the west property line of the petitioners commercial parcel.  
Location: District 5; The parcel is unaddressed; S22/T22/R32; Orange County Comptroller  
County, Florida (legal property description on file)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Bonilla, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, to  
approve the request listed in the Staff Report dated March 5, 2024. The motion carried by the  
following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
C. Shoreline Alteration/Dredge and Fill  
11.  
Mohammed I. Khan Life Estate, Shamim K. Khan Life Estate, Mohammed  
Ayaz Khan, Nida Imtiaz Khan and Amber Imtiaz Khan, Big Sand Lake,  
permit; District 1  
Consideration: Request for  
a
Shoreline Alteration/Dredge and Fill Permit Application  
(SADF-23-10-026) to authorize the construction of a replacement vinyl seawall along the  
shoreline of Big Sand Lake, pursuant to Chapter 15, Article VI, Pumping and Dredging Control  
Location: District 1; on property located adjacent to Big Sand Lake, located at 9049 Southern  
Breeze Drive, Orlando, Florida 32836 (legal property description on file in Environmental  
Protection Division)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Wilson, seconded by Commissioner Scott, to accept the  
findings and recommendation of the Environmental Protection Division; and further, approve the  
Shoreline Alteration/Dredge and Fill Permit (SADF-23-10-026) subject to the twenty-five (25)  
conditions of approval listed in the Staff Report dated January 30, 2024. The motion carried by  
the following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
D. Board of Zoning Adjustment Appeal  
12.  
Herbert Betancourt, January 4, 2024; District 5  
Consideration: Appeal of the recommendation of the Board of Zoning Adjustment on a request  
by applicant for Variances in the R-1AA zoning district as follows: 1) To allow for an existing  
detached accessory structure dwelling unit* (treehouse) 11 ft. from the Normal High Water  
Elevation (NHWE) in lieu of 35 ft. 2) To allow an existing detached accessory structure (gazebo)  
3.8 ft. from the Normal High Water Elevation (NHWE) in lieu of 35 ft. 3) To allow an existing  
detached accessory structure (outdoor shower) 12.9 ft. from the Normal High Water Elevation  
(NHWE) in lieu of 35 ft. 4) To allow an existing detached accessory structure (pergola) 15.1 ft.  
from the Normal High Water Elevation (NHWE) in lieu of 35 ft. 5) To allow an existing pool/deck  
with a south side setback of 3.5 ft. in lieu of 5 ft. Note: This is a result of Code Enforcement  
*Accessory dwelling unit was advertised, but not applicable.  
Location: District 5; property located at 4715 Shorecrest Dr., Orlando, FL 32817 (legal property  
description on file at Zoning Division)  
Based on the updated site plan received February 27, 2024; Variances in the R-1AA zoning  
district as follows:  
1) To allow for an existing detached accessory structure (treehouse) 11 ft. from the Normal High  
Water Elevation (NHWE) in lieu of 35 ft.  
2) To allow an existing detached accessory structure (gazebo) 3.8 ft. from the Normal High Water  
Elevation (NHWE) in lieu of 35 ft.  
3) To allow an existing detached accessory structure (outdoor shower) 12.9 ft. from the Normal  
High Water Elevation (NHWE) in lieu of 35 ft.  
4) To allow an existing detached accessory structure (pergola) 15.1 ft. from the Normal High  
Water Elevation (NHWE) in lieu of 35 ft.  
5) To allow an existing pool/deck with a south side setback of 3.5 ft. in lieu of 5 ft.  
Five (5) Conditions of Approval as follows:  
1. Development shall be in accordance with the site plan received February 27, 2024, survey  
received November 20, 2023, and elevations received October 11, 2023 as modified to remove  
the treehouse, pergola, and outdoor shower structure, subject to the conditions of approval, and  
all applicable laws, ordinances, and regulations. Any proposed non-substantial deviations,  
changes, or modifications will be subject to the Zoning Manager's review and approval. Any  
proposed substantial deviations, changes, or modifications will be subject to a public hearing  
before the Board of Zoning Adjustment (BZA) where the BZA makes a recommendation to the  
Board of County Commissioners (BCC).  
2. Pursuant to Section 125.022, Florida Statutes, issuance of this development permit by the  
County does not in any way create any rights on the part of the applicant to obtain a permit from a  
state or federal agency and does not create any liability on the part of the County for issuance of  
the permit if the applicant fails to obtain requisite approvals or fulfill the obligations imposed by a  
state or federal agency or undertakes actions that result in a violation of state or federal law.  
Pursuant to Section 125.022, the applicant shall obtain all other applicable state or federal  
permits before commencement of development.  
3. Any deviation from a Code standard not specifically identified and reviewed/addressed by the  
Board of County Commissioners shall be resubmitted for the Board's review or the plans revised  
to comply with the standard.  
4. Prior to the issuance of any building permit of the existing detached structures and the pool and  
deck, the portion of the fence which encroaches into the adjacent property shall be removed.  
5. Prior to the issuance of any building permit, the property owner shall record in the official  
records of Orange County, Florida an Indemnification/Hold Harmless Agreement, on a form  
provided by the County, which indemnifies Orange County, Florida from any damages and losses  
arising out of or related in any way to the activities or operations on or use of the Improvement  
resulting from the County's granting of the Variance request and, which shall inform all interested  
parties that the gazebo is located no closer than 3.8 feet from the Normal High Water Elevation  
(NHWE) of Lake Martha.  
The following persons addressed the Board:  
- George Sharpe (phonetic)  
- Herbert Betancourt  
A motion was made by Commissioner Bonilla, seconded by Commissioner Scott, to uphold the  
Board of Zoning Adjustment Recommendation of January 4, 2024, Case # VA-23-12-119, to  
deny Variances #1, #3, and #4, and approve Variances #2 and #5 in the R-1AA zoning district;  
and further, approve the five (5) conditions of approval. The motion carried by the following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
E. Preliminary Subdivision Plan  
13.  
Stephen Allen, Civil Corp Engineering, Inc., Marbella Reserve Preliminary  
Subdivision Plan; District 3  
Consideration: Marbella Reserve Preliminary Subdivision Plan, Case  
#
PSP-22-03-091,  
submitted in accordance with Orange County Code, Chapter 34, Article III, Section 34-69 and  
Chapter 30, Article III, Section 30-89; This Preliminary Subdivision Plan (PSP) is a request to  
subdivide 4.40 acres in order to construct 12 single-family residential dwelling units.  
Location: District 3; property generally located South of East Colonial Drive / West of Dean  
Road, Orange County, Florida (legal property description on file in Planning Division)  
New Conditions of Approval #23 & #24:  
23. The applicant/developer shall install or have caused to install a fence acceptable to County  
along the upland buffer line adjacent to and within Tract F connecting the existing stormwater  
pond fences to the north and south of this subdivision, prior to Certificate of Completion.  
24. A 6 ft. tall opaque PVC fence shall be installed along the south property lines of Tract F, and  
Lots 1-12, prior to Certificate of Completion.  
The following person addressed the Board: Stephen Allen.  
A motion was made by Commissioner Uribe, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero, to  
make a finding of consistency with the Comprehensive Plan; further, approve the request subject  
to the twenty-two (22) conditions of approval listed under the Development Review Committee  
Recommendation in the Staff Report dated February 12, 2024; and further, approve new  
Conditions of Approval #23 and #24. The motion carried by the following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
14.  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
Solange Dao, P.E., DAO Consultants, Inc., Wedgefield 10 Lot Addition -  
Block 40 Preliminary Subdivision Plan; District 5 (Continued from February  
6, 2024)  
Consideration: Wedgefield 10 Lot Addition - Block 40 Preliminary Subdivision Plan (PSP),  
Case # CDR-22-05-162, submitted in accordance with Orange County Code, Chapter 34, Article  
III, Section 34-69 and Chapter 30, Article III, Section 30-89; This Preliminary Subdivision Plan  
(PSP) is a request to subdivide 2.13 acres to construct four single-family residential dwelling  
units.  
Location: District 5; property generally located North of Maxim Parkway / South of Macon  
Parkway / East of Bancroft Boulevard, Orange County, Florida (legal property description on file  
in Planning Division)  
A motion was made by Commissioner Bonilla, seconded by Commissioner Scott, to make a  
finding of consistency with the Comprehensive Plan; and further, approve the request subject to  
the seventeen (17) conditions of approval listed under the Development Review Committee  
Recommendation in the Staff Report dated February 12, 2024. The motion carried by the  
following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
F. Ordinance/Comprehensive Plan - Adoption of Small-Scale Amendments and  
Ordinance  
15.  
Ordinance, William Bywater  
a. Amendment SS-23-12-100  
Consideration: To change the Future Land Use designation from Neighborhood Activity Center  
(NAC) to Commercial (C) in order to allow for C-2 zoning district uses including but not limited to  
outdoor storage and sales of automobiles; pursuant to Part II, Chapter 163, Florida Statutes and  
Orange County Code  
Location: District 6; property located at 1013 W. Michigan Street; generally located on the north  
side of W. Michigan Street, west of S. Westmoreland Drive; Orange County, Florida (legal  
property description on file in Planning Division)  
And  
b. Ordinance for Proposed Amendment  
Consideration: An Ordinance pertaining to Comprehensive Planning in Orange County, Florida;  
Amending the Orange County Comprehensive Plan, commonly known as the “2010-2030  
Comprehensive Plan,” as amended, by adopting Small-Scale development amendments  
pursuant to Section 163.3187, Florida Statutes; and providing effective dates.  
The following person addressed the Board: William Bywater.  
The following material was presented to the Board prior to the close of the public hearing: Exhibit  
1, from William Bywater.  
A motion was made by Commissioner Scott, seconded by Commissioner Uribe, to make a  
finding of inconsistency with the Comprehensive Plan; further, deny the Commercial (C) Future  
Land Use; and further, deny the associated Ordinance. The motion carried by the following vote:  
7 -  
Aye:  
Mayor Demings, Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Moore, Commissioner  
Uribe, Commissioner Gomez Cordero, Commissioner Bonilla, and Commissioner  
Scott  
The notated public hearing is quasi-judicial in nature. As such, any verbal or written  
communication with a member of the Board of County Commissioners prior to today’s  
quasi-judicial hearing should be disclosed on the record or made a part of the record  
during the public hearing by or on behalf of the party who communicated with the Board  
member to allow any interested party an opportunity to inquire about or respond to such  
communication. Failure to disclose any such communication may place the party who  
ultimately prevails at the quasi-judicial hearing at risk of having the Board’s decision  
overturned in a court of law due to prejudice against the party who was not privy to the  
ex parte communication.  
Information regarding meetings held at the County Administration Building between any  
member of the Board and an outside party may be obtained at  
ADJOURNMENT: 3:13 p.m.  
ATTEST:  
_____________________________  
County Mayor Jerry L. Demings  
Date: ________________________  
ATTEST SIGNATURE:  
Phil Diamond__________________  
County Comptroller as Clerk  
_____________________________  
Deputy Clerk  
* * *  
Any person wishing to appeal any decision made by the Board of County  
Commissioners at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings. For that purpose,  
such person may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,  
which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be  
based.  
In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), if any person with a  
disability as defined by the ADA needs special accommodation to participate in this  
proceeding, then not later than two (2) business days prior to the proceeding, he or she  
should contact the Orange County Communications Division at (407) 836-5517.  
Para mayor información en español, por favor llame al (407) 836-3111.  
Si w bezwen èd nan lang Kreyòl oswa sèvis tradiksyon, tanpri rele (407) 836-3111  
NOTE: Reports from the County Mayor, the County Commissioners, the County  
Administrator, and the County Attorney may be presented at unscheduled times  
throughout the day, depending on the length of time required for advertised public  
hearings.  
Copies of Specific Project Expenditure Reports and Relationship Disclosure Forms are  
not included with agenda items unless there is a listed expenditure or disclosure.  
Copies of these completed reports and forms may be obtained by contacting the  
relevant Department/Division Office.